I thought Dedenne could have potentially been given the Associate’s gun potentially a different night, but looking at that a little harder I could’ve misinterpreted it. I’d still try to be careful though.
You’re saying that having a single-use action is grounds for not being the Hooker? An odd defense, although maybe that’s more grounds for suspicion than I thought. Looking back, the first people to propose the Hooker theory were Desi as a hypothesis, but then Johnny (as Gramps) doubled down on that as one of the few things he said; why would he be so sure of that when it’s just more information on the Mafia? And in fact, agreeing there was a Hooker was one of the few things you didn’t copy from me. I feel like we might’ve been duped about the whole Hooker business entirely.
In retrospect, that line might well have meant that someone tried to kill Aaron when he roleblocked them; there were only two deaths on Day One, but we’ve confirmed that there’s still two killers and vulg would’ve been checking whether his NA did anything, so what accounts for that death?
The only one-use action we’ve seen in prior games is the Strongman, if I recall, but otherwise Town has never had any. If there’s only one Town role we don’t know anymore, and none of the others have been single-use, only visiting or non-visiting, I highly doubt that GP only gave them that privilege. So actually, with this clarified, I think that’s even more affirmative for me.
Are you telling me I shouldn’t go after people I find scum? If you need any reminders, I was the one that thought you were scum to start with, which is what brought it to Dedenne’s attention because it was odd behavior. Unless you just want inconsistency from me, so you can call me out on that instead.
With regards to the TP Killer, I think I’d be more concerned with the Mafia tbh, because unless the TP is the Autocrat, Town still wins if they lynch Mafia, and we can only lynch one person. Your insistence on drawing attention away attention from Mafia and being sus of everyone but the confirmed Priest just looks like you’re backed into a corner to me.
EDIT: Oh, and about your request for information, before you knew Trickster’s visits were random, you seemed awfully concerned with knowing who visited who. It’s kind of obvious that Mafia had the most to gain from that, because it would narrow down Mafia’s idea of who the Trickster was to one or two people, but narrow Town’s pool of suspects to… everyone who was visited? And that would only help us target one Mafia, if you believed what you were saying, but Johnny corrected you on that conveniently fast.