I wanted to agree that they should reveal, but only if they have information and if they have one that is fine, we are in a situation that might cause us to not have another day if a gun is shot off wrong and we lynch incorrectly. We can’t wait around for 2 or 3 and I just wanted to state that I believe there to be a max of 3 mafia, two goons and an Illusionist which btw:
Starts the game with a gun. Can choose someone during the night and when the gun is fired, it will appear to have been shot by the person chosen.
So if we have 8 people, and the mafia have three, and they have TWO kills possible, then this could technically be lynch or lose. So I would almost guarantee we have 3 mafia members with a slight possibility of two, but very little.
I was only looking at yesterday, in which Shiny wasn’t active at all from what I see in that, to the extent of the others listed at least.